Canada needs a major politician who will question the world’s most damaging alliance.
On Wednesday leftist French presidential candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon told an audience: “The countries of NATO account for 80% of the world’s military spending. It is not true that the others are armed to the teeth against us. What is true is that we belong to a coalition that threatens everyone.”
Over the past 25 years NATO has bombed Libya and Yugoslavia as well as occupying Afghanistan. More recently, NATO has engaged in a major proxy war with Russia and assisted the US/Israeli war on Iran while soon after its 1949 creation the alliance helped European colonial powers supress anti-colonial movements.
Polling second in a vote scheduled for April, Mélenchon has repeatedly said he would withdraw France from NATO, which would have major geopolitical ripples. His campaign reiterated the call in their just released platform, which immediately sold out its initial 80,000 book print-run.
While Mélenchon is closest to having the power to make the move, other significant voices oppose NATO. Podemos in Spain, Die Linke in Germany and Greece’s Communist Party all call for withdrawing their countries from NATO. In the UK former Labour MPs and Your Party co-leaders, Zarah Sultana and Jeremy Corbyn, have called for withdrawal while Green Party leader Zack Polanski wants England to eventually abandon its NATO membership. Even in the US Green Party presidential candidate Jill Stein has repeatedly called for withdrawing from NATO.
But no major Canadian politician directly criticizes NATO, let alone demands immediate withdrawal.
Recently anointed head of the Green party leader, Mike Morrice backs the belligerent military alliance. During the 2025 election, reported CBC, “Morrice said one issue he’s heard in his community is the need to strengthen Canada’s defence, including getting defence spending to the NATO benchmark of two per cent of GDP.” Last year outgoing Green leader Elizabeth May called NATO a “necessary bulwark against authoritarian regimes.”
After NDP members passed an anti-NATO resolution in 1969, the party’s official policy was to withdraw from the alliance. Even though members never voted to rescind the call, party leadership abandoned that position two decades later and new leftist NDP leader Avi Lewis hasn’t changed direction. Lewis has largely refused to mention the alliance except to say he considers NATO spending targets arbitrary. But a year ago Lewis also said he backed Canada sending more arms to fight Russia and he reappointed Heather McPherson as NDP foreign affairs critic. McPherson is a member of the NATO parliamentary assembly who promoted Ukraine joining NATO before Russia’s 2022 invasion and subsequently got Parliament to unanimously back a motion calling on Canada to “support Ukraine’s future membership in NATO.”
With no politician of any significant stature articulating a critical position towards NATO, Carney can double, triple and quadruple down on the alliance. On Saturday the PM said, “the security architecture for free Europe will be determined by free Europe and NATO, not by Russia and a redux of the Minsk agreement.” He added, “There’s no way that Canada as a NATO member is going to walk away from any other NATO member — ever.”
In practice, Carney’s position means sending ever more Canadian soldiers to Latvia and arms/budget support to Ukraine while opposing diplomacy to end the horrible war. It also means devoting ever more of our public resources on militarism.
According to polling, a quarter of Canadians have an unfavourable view of NATO. Imagine the proportion who would be against it if a major politician called for withdrawing from the belligerent military alliance.
Support Yves’ work. Donate Now.

You must be logged in to post a comment.